The quick take
Choosing between CDPAP (Consumer Directed Personal Assistance Program) and traditional home care through a licensed agency is really a choice between control and convenience. CDPAP gives you the power to select, train, and schedule a caregiver you trust, often a family member or friend, while New York Medicaid authorizes the weekly hours and a Fiscal Intermediary (FI) runs payroll and EVV. Traditional home care hands off recruiting, supervision, scheduling, and replacements to an agency; hours are similarly authorized by your Medicaid plan (or you can pay privately). This guide helps you decide which fits your household, then shows how Individual Home Care can set it up without gaps.
What CDPAP actually offers
You choose the caregiver. The consumer, or a Designated Representative if they cannot self-direct, recruits and directs the caregiver (often a relative or friend).
- Common restrictions: Spouses and parents of a minor child are typically not eligible to be paid caregivers.
- Hours come from an assessment. A nurse evaluates needs; your managed care plan authorizes a weekly number of hours.
- FI handles payroll & compliance. The Fiscal Intermediary manages onboarding, taxes, and Electronic Visit Verification (EVV); you approve time.
- Daily control. You set tasks and schedule within the authorized hours.
Best for: families who want a trusted person, specific language/cultural match, and flexible scheduling tied to real routines. Individual Home Care can coach you on onboarding, EVV, and backup plans.
What traditional agency home care offers
- Turnkey staffing. The agency recruits, background-checks, trains, and supervises aides.
- Coverage & replacements. If an aide calls out, the agency works to find a substitute.
- Nurse oversight. Agencies adjust care plans as needs change and provide coaching to the household.
- Hours & payment. With Medicaid, hours are authorized after assessment; with private pay, you choose the schedule and pay the agency’s rate.
Best for: households that prefer less admin, want supervision, and need quick access to additional staff (e.g., adding an awake-overnight shift after a hospitalization). Individual Home Care coordinates schedules, fit, and escalations.
A plain-English comparison
Control vs. Convenience
- CDPAP = maximum control over who, when, and how tasks are done.
- Agency = maximum convenience; staffing and supervision are managed for you.
Staffing reality
- CDPAP depends on the person you choose showing up reliably and on time.
- Agency sends trained aides and, when possible, replacements if someone is out.
Scheduling
- CDPAP is ideal for split shifts (short morning/evening blocks) or unusual hours.
- Agency is ideal when you need awake-overnight coverage or multiple aides.
Paperwork
- CDPAP gives you power, and responsibility (timesheets/EVV approvals, day-to-day coordination).
- Agency reduces paperwork; you still communicate changes but don’t run payroll or onboarding.
Cost & coverage
- Under Medicaid, authorized hours are funded in both models; you still budget for supplies, transport, and any required spend-down.
- For private-pay, agency hourly or live-in rates apply; some families use private-pay short term while pursuing Medicaid.
Individual Home Care helps you blend models too: for example, CDPAP weekdays with an agency covering nights or weekends.
How to tell which model fits your routine
- Do we have a reliable caregiver candidate?
If yes, CDPAP can boost trust and continuity. - Is language/culture a make-or-break factor?
CDPAP lets you lock this in; agency can try to match, but it’s not guaranteed. - Are our hardest times short and predictable (mornings/evenings)?
CDPAP handles predictable split shifts beautifully. - Do we need nurse oversight and easy replacements?
Agency shines when supervision and backup coverage are critical. - Do nights require hands-on help?
Agency is often the fastest path to awake-overnight staffing when justified. - Do we have bandwidth to manage timesheets, EVV, and scheduling?
If not, agency reduces your admin burden. If yes, CDPAP gives you control.
If your answers land on both sides, Individual Home Care can design a hybrid that protects safety and preserves continuity.
Real-world scenarios
Scenario A: Trust first.
Your mother only accepts bathing help from her niece who speaks her first language. CDPAP lets you hire the niece, schedule consistent times, and keep dignity high. Individual Home Care sets up FI onboarding, EVV, and a backup plan.
Scenario B: Nights became risky.
After rehab, your father needs bathroom help at 1 a.m. and 4 a.m. An agency can staff awake overnights faster, with nurse oversight and replacements. Meanwhile, Individual Home Care helps you request a reassessment so hours officially cover nights.
Scenario C: You’re juggling work.
You can’t manage shift coverage and timesheets. Agency care carries the admin while Individual Home Care aligns schedules and escalates for better fit when needed.
Scenario D: You want both.
Use CDPAP for daytime consistency with a trusted person and an agency for weekends and nights. Individual Home Care blends the calendar so gaps don’t appear.
What it takes to start CDPAP
- Confirm Medicaid path. If not enrolled yet, begin Community Medicaid/MLTC; address spend-down or a pooled income trust if applicable.
- Request assessment. A nurse visit determines weekly hours based on ADLs and safety needs.
- Select an FI. Compare onboarding speed, language support, customer service, and payroll cadence.
- Onboard your caregiver. ID/work authorization, health forms as required, direct deposit, EVV app setup.
- Begin services & track time. Approve EVV; keep a simple log in case needs change.
If needs rise (falls, nighttime toileting), Individual Home Care helps you log specifics and request reassessment promptly.
What it takes to start agency care
- Choose the agency. Ask about staffing depth for your time windows, language matches, and backup procedures.
- Clarify coverage. Medicaid-authorized hours vs private-pay; pick start dates and priority blocks (mornings/evenings, nights).
- Home safety check. Confirm chair height, grab bars, lighting, and equipment that aides will use.
- Start and adjust. If the match isn’t right, request changes; if nights prove harder than expected, add short blocks or pursue reassessment.
Individual Home Care coordinates the pieces, so you spend less time on hold and more time in a steady routine.
Cutting stress and cost whichever path you choose
- Aim support at peak risk. Morning/evening routines and nights cause most falls, cover those first.
- Standardize routines. A consistent toileting plan and simple transfer cues (“nose over toes”) speed up care safely.
- Use only the gear that matters. Non-skid socks, a gait belt, and well-placed grab bars reduce injuries (and ER bills).
- Blend services. Adult day + shorter home shifts; CDPAP for daytime + agency overnights.
- Document changes. If you’re privately covering nights because of new risks, keep logs; ask for a reassessment so Medicaid hours match reality.
When you’re unsure where to start, Individual Home Care can map your week into a clear schedule and budget in one call.
The bottom line
Pick the model that fits your routine today, not an ideal you hope to maintain. If trust and language fit are non-negotiable and you have a reliable person, CDPAP gives you control. If you need staffing, supervision, and backups without the admin, agency care is simpler. If you need both, combine them. Individual Home Care helps you decide, set up services, and adjust when life changes, as it always does.
Ready to choose with confidence?
Get a side-by-side plan tailored to your week, who helps, when, and how it’s covered, without guesswork.
Talk to a Care Planner